top of page
Search

Pacifiers: Listening to What a Baby Is Telling Us

12 minutes ago
6 min read

I was waiting in line at the IKEA checkout one day behind a young family: a mother, a father, and a young infant, whom the mother was carrying in a baby carrier. The baby began to cry. The baby’s cries intensified. The mother took out a pacifier, pushed it hard into the baby’s mouth, and said, “Here, this is for your cry hole.” The father stood behind the shopping cart. He did not move to support the mother or the baby, and from where I stood, he did not seem aware of how that moment felt for his own child.


My husband quietly stepped in front of our cart, placing himself between that family and me. He knew I was not going to say anything. He moved to set me up to be successful: with him in my line of sight, I could lean on him to regulate myself. It was a small, quiet act of partnership. My general practice is not to interfere in moments like these, because a stranger stepping in when help was not asked for is rarely supportive of a parent who is already struggling. I did not know this mother or this father, or how they had set things up to support each other. Still, it was hard to watch, and it broke my heart.


At the same time, I could understand each of them. The mother seemed dysregulated and in need of support herself. The baby was crying to communicate a need. And the father, standing still behind the cart, may not have known how to help. The checkout was loud and brightly lit, with people talking all around us, and that much stimulation is hard on everyone, especially a young infant. The pacifier stopped the crying. But what was that baby trying to tell us?


At Bridges Care and Education Center, our philosophy is built on close relationships (Bridges Care and Education Center, n.d.-a), and our practice is inspired by Magda Gerber’s Educaring Approach®, taught by Resources for Infant Educarers® (RIE®). Both lead us to see a baby’s cry not as a problem to quiet, but as a message to understand.


Crying is communication


Crying is an infant’s primary way of communicating. At BCEC, we aim to respond, not react. Reacting tries to stop the crying as quickly as possible, often through distraction. Responding means calmly approaching the child and, together, taking care of the unmet need (Bridges Care and Education Center, n.d.-b).


A pacifier offered the moment a baby cries is often a reaction. The crying stops, but the need behind it may still be there. Stopping crying through distraction can also interfere with a child’s ability to calm their own body when they are ready. Children need to learn to trust their own bodies (Bridges Care and Education Center, n.d.-b).


Everyone has the right to cry


That moment at IKEA reflects an unfair pressure our society places on the adults who care for young children. When a baby cries in public, we look at the adult holding them as if they have failed. In truth, everyone has the right to cry, and children have the right to cry wherever they are. They are expressing themselves and communicating. Many believe crying is also one of the ways our bodies release stress and find their way back to a regulated state.


Babies do not come into this world needing pacifiers for comfort. They are born with a natural sucking reflex, and with their own hands and thumbs to comfort themselves. The need for a pacifier is often created by well-meaning adults, shaped largely by societal pressure and by their own tolerance for the sounds of crying.


Children are dependents. They depend on the adults who brought them into this world to meet their needs, to protect them, to help them regulate, and to model and guide them for the rest of their lives. A crying infant is not misbehaving. Crying is one way that a dependent child is asking the adults they depend on for support.


What Magda Gerber’s Educaring Approach® asks of us


As RIE® describes it, respect is the basis of Magda Gerber’s Educaring Approach®. We trust each child to be an initiator, an explorer, and a self-learner, and we observe closely to understand each baby’s communication and needs (Resources for Infant Educarers®, n.d.).


Magda Gerber (n.d.) wrote about pacifiers directly in her “Dear Magda” column, “Thumb or Pacifier.” She explained that the real question is not which one is better, but who is in control. When an adult decides that a baby needs a pacifier, the adult is deciding how the baby should feel. A baby’s own thumb, by contrast, belongs to the baby and is always available, so the baby decides when they need comfort and for how long.


Resting on their back and free to move, this baby has found their own fingers. Self-comfort, on their own terms.
Resting on their back and free to move, this baby has found their own fingers. Self-comfort, on their own terms.

Before reaching for a pacifier


When a baby cries, we slow down, observe, and tell them what we see: “You are crying. I am here. I am listening.” Then we look for the unmet need:

•         Is the baby hungry?

•         Is the baby tired?

•         Is the baby uncomfortable, too warm, too cold, or in need of a fresh diaper?

•         Does the baby need closeness?

•         Does the baby simply need to express a feeling and be heard?

Sometimes the need is met quickly. Sometimes a baby needs to cry in the arms of a regulated, present adult. Both are part of building trust.


Setting ourselves up for success


Because children depend on us, it is our responsibility, as parents, guardians, and anyone else who cares for young children, to prepare ourselves to meet their needs in a developmentally appropriate way, and to set ourselves up to succeed. Standing in that line at IKEA, these questions ran through my mind:


•         Could one parent have gone shopping while the other stayed home with the baby, following the baby’s regular routine?

•         If both parents wanted a day out together, was there a babysitter or family member who could continue the baby’s routine at home?

•         How do these partners plan to support each other in hard moments, while also protecting their child?


None of us is at our best when we are overstimulated and unsupported, and babies are no different. Planning ahead and agreeing as partners on how to step in for each other, protects both the adults and the child.


When babies find their own comfort


Many babies discover their thumbs, fingers, or hands on their own. When they do, they are taking an early step toward self-regulation: the ability to monitor and manage their own feelings and behavior (Thompson, 2009, as cited in Bridges Care and Education Center, n.d.-b). Infants develop self-regulation with the support of caring partners (Elliot & Gonzalez-Mena, 2011, as cited in Bridges Care and Education Center, n.d.-b), and a baby who learns that they can comfort themselves, and that an adult will come when they need help, gains trust in themselves and in the people around them.


Pacifiers at BCEC


Every family makes their own decisions about pacifiers, often with guidance from their pediatrician, and we respect those decisions. At BCEC, we partner with families so that a pacifier, when a child uses one, is offered in response to the child’s cues rather than as a quick way to quiet crying. We always look first for what the child is communicating. We follow the same pacifier routine that the child is used to and then, in partnership with the family, look for opportunities to put it away when the child seems to no longer need it.


Bringing it home


If you would like to try this with your family, here are a few places to start:

•         If you use a pacifier, pause before offering it. Take a breath, observe, and ask yourself what your baby might need.

•         Talk to your baby. “You are crying. I am here. I am listening.” Even the youngest infant feels the difference between being quieted and being heard.

•         Know your own limits. How tolerant are you of loud sounds, including your own child’s cries? If you are reaching your limit, switch with your partner and take a break. Stepping away to regulate yourself is a way of caring for your child, too.


A pacifier can silence a cry, but it cannot answer one. Only a caring adult can do that. Every time we choose to listen instead of silence, a baby learns that their feelings matter, that their voice is important and will be heard, and that they can trust themselves and the people who care for them. That trust is not built in a single moment. It is built cry by cry, and it lasts a lifetime.


To learn more, read about our philosophy at bridgescareandeducationcenter.com/philosophy, and about Magda Gerber’s Educaring Approach® at rie.org/educaring-approach.


References


Bridges Care and Education Center. (n.d.-a). Philosophy. Retrieved November 17, 2026, from https://www.bridgescareandeducationcenter.com/philosophy


Bridges Care and Education Center. (n.d.-b). Support crying. Retrieved November 17, 2026, from https://www.bridgescareandeducationcenter.com/why-support-crying


Gerber, M. (n.d.). Thumb or pacifier [Dear Magda column]. Magda Gerber Legacy. Retrieved November 17, 2026, from https://magdagerber.org/dear-magda/thumb-or-pacifier/


Resources for Infant Educarers®. (n.d.). Educaring® approach. Retrieved November 17, 2026, from https://rie.org/educaring-approach/


 
 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.

Center Information

Hours of Operation for Bridges 8:00 am - 5:30pm Monday-Friday

​

Contact Us

Location

BRIDGES | East Lansing, MI 

​

RIE®, Educaring®, and Resources for Infant Educarers® and associated marks are licensed trademarks of Resources for Infant Educarers® (www.RIE.org). 

 

Disclaimer:  Information presented on this website is based on the current knowledge base of Abhirami Gunasingam .  Links are being provided as a convenience and for informational purposes only; they do not constitute an endorsement or an approval in any manner.  Information will be modified  as needed.

website design | Peanut Butter Creative

bottom of page