Telling Children the Truth
“The playground is closed.” “The ice cream truck only plays music when it has run out of ice cream.” “This will not hurt a bit.” “I will be right back.” Most of us have heard these words, and many of us have said them. They are small, well-meaning lies, often told to avoid tears, to get out the door, or to make a hard moment pass a little faster.
They work in the moment. But young children are always learning what our words mean, and every small lie teaches them something we never meant to teach: that the words of the adults they depend on cannot always be trusted.
Trust is built in the earliest years
At Bridges Care and Education Center, we believe trust is the foundation of everything we do. During the first year of life, the way caregivers respond shapes a baby’s trust in others, in themselves, and in their environment (Bridges Care and Education Center, n.d.-b). Young children cannot yet check what we tell them against the world. They simply believe us.
When what we say does not match what happens, children notice. The playground that was “closed” is full of children the next day. The shot that “will not hurt” does hurt. The parent who will “be right back” is gone all day. Each time, the child learns a little more that they cannot rely on what adults tell them.
Parents are a child’s first relationship
A child’s first relationships are with their parents. Those relationships become the model for every relationship that follows: with caregivers, teachers, friends, and one day, partners and children of their own. When the people a child trusts most tell them things that are not true, even small and loving untruths, it quietly undermines the trust that relationship is built on.

What about Santa, the Easter Bunny, the Tooth Fairy, and Halloween?
For many families, these stories are a cherished part of childhood, told with love and joy. Still, they ask children to believe something that is not true, on the word of the adults they trust most. Eventually, every child finds out the truth about Santa Claus, the Easter Bunny, and the Tooth Fairy. And deep down, I believe children often sense that something is missing long before they are told. To keep believing, they must disconnect from the truth they feel in their own bodies and live in a world at home that feels different from what they know to be true. When the truth finally comes out, many children are left wondering what else they were told that was not real.
Halloween brings its own challenges. Masks, costumes, and spooky decorations can be confusing and frightening for young children, who are still learning where pretend ends and real begins. When adults hide behind masks, tell children that ghosts or monsters will get them, or brush off a child’s fear with “It is not scary,” the child’s real experience is dismissed. Honesty can look like taking off a mask so a child can see the familiar face underneath, saying, “That is a person wearing a costume,” and respecting a child who does not want to take part.
There is another way to keep the joy. Children love pretend play, and they understand it earlier than we often think. Families can share these stories as stories, enjoy the traditions together, and play pretend, while answering honestly when a child sincerely asks, “Is it real?” The wonder does not have to come from a lie.
Do not dumb it down
Honesty also means not dumbing things down. Magda Gerber’s Educaring Approach® recognizes that children, at any age, understand a great deal about what is going on around them, and encourages adults to speak to them in natural language rather than baby talk (Gonzalez-Mena, 1976/1980). At BCEC, we use real words: the correct names for body parts, “The fish died” rather than “The fish went to sleep,” and “Dada is at work and will pick you up after nap” rather than “Mama will be right back.” Simple, honest words respect a child’s ability to understand their world.
What Magda Gerber’s Educaring Approach® asks of us
As RIE® describes it, respect is the basis of Magda Gerber’s Educaring Approach®, and the goal is an authentic child: one who feels secure, autonomous, competent, and connected (Resources for Infant Educarers®, n.d.). Telling children the truth is one of the clearest ways we show that respect.
In “Ten Steps to the Educaring® Approach,” Janet Gonzalez-Mena (1976/1980) offers practical guidance that speaks directly to honesty. Adults are encouraged to tell a baby what they are about to do before they do it and to give the baby a chance to respond. They are encouraged to be honest about their own feelings, rather than pretending to feel something they do not, and to avoid sending mixed messages. And to build security through trust, adults are encouraged never to leave without telling the child.
Honesty at BCEC
Honesty is woven into our everyday routines:
• Telling children what will happen. During diaper meetings, we invite each child to get their diaper changed, wait for them to respond, and use self-talk to describe each step (Bridges Care and Education Center, n.d.-a). Children always know what is happening to their bodies and why.
• Saying goodbye. The first diaper change of the day is a morning meeting with each child, which supports the transition to group care away from family members (Bridges Care and Education Center, n.d.-a). We support families in saying a clear goodbye rather than slipping away while their child is busy playing. A child who sees their parent leave, and then sees them return, learns that goodbyes can be trusted.
• Telling the truth about discomfort. If something may hurt or feel uncomfortable, we say so: “This might sting. I am right here with you.”
• Giving the real reason. Instead of “The toys are tired,” we say, “It is time to clean up because lunch is ready.”
• Being honest about our own feelings. “I feel frustrated right now. I am going to take a deep breath and sit down for a few minutes beside you.” Children learn that feelings can be named and handled honestly.
The truth, told with care
Telling children the truth does not mean telling them everything, or telling it harshly. It means choosing simple, honest words that fit the child’s age, and staying present while they feel whatever comes next. Sometimes the most honest answer is, “That is a grown-up matter, and I am taking care of it.” That is still the truth.
The truth may bring tears. A child may cry when they hear that the park visit is over or that their parent is leaving for work. Those tears are not a sign that honesty failed. They are a sign that the child trusted us enough to feel the real moment, with a caring adult beside them.
Bringing it home
If you would like to try this with your family, here are a few places to start:
• Always say goodbye. Even when it brings tears, a clear goodbye builds more trust than slipping away.
• Tell your child what will happen. “After your bath, we will put on pajamas and read one book.”
• Give the real reason. “We are leaving the park because it is time for dinner,” not “The park is closing.”
• Be honest about hard things. “The doctor will give you a shot. It will pinch for a moment, and I will hold you.”
• Keep your promises. If you say you will come back after nap, come back after nap.
Every small lie may make a moment easier, but every truth makes a relationship stronger. When we tell children the truth, even when it is hard, we are telling them something deeper: you can trust me. That is a gift that lasts a lifetime.
To learn more, read about our philosophy at bridgescareandeducationcenter.com/philosophy, and about Magda Gerber’s Educaring Approach® at rie.org/educaring-approach.
References
Bridges Care and Education Center. (n.d.-a). Diaper meetings. Retrieved November 18, 2026, from https://www.bridgescareandeducationcenter.com/diaper-meetings
Bridges Care and Education Center. (n.d.-b). Support crying. Retrieved November 18, 2026, from https://www.bridgescareandeducationcenter.com/why-support-crying
Gonzalez-Mena, J. (1980). Ten steps to the Educaring® approach. Educaring®, 1(4). https://rie.org/?p=26295 (Original work published 1976)
Resources for Infant Educarers®. (n.d.). Educaring® approach. Retrieved November 18, 2026, from https://rie.org/educaring-approach/

Comments